What Seeds Should Not Be Planted In Toilet Paper Rolls

Large seeds such as squash and beans, deep-rooting plants like carrots and parsnips, and those requiring special conditions, for example, strawberries and certain herbs, could be better suited for toilet paper roll planting.

Intrigued? Read on to unearth why these seeds rebel against the confines of a humble toilet paper roll.

We’ll journey together through the nuanced world of gardening, exploring how you can best use this innovative, eco-friendly seed-starting method while sidestepping potential pitfalls.

Brief Explanation of the Trend of Planting Seeds in Toilet Paper Rolls

Planting seeds in toilet paper rolls has surged in popularity recently, primarily driven by an increased interest in sustainable and cost-effective gardening. It’s a method of starting your seeds indoors before they’re ready to be transplanted outdoors, with toilet paper rolls serving as biodegradable seed pots.

This practice not only reuses an item commonly discarded as waste but also allows for a seamless transition for seedlings from indoors to outdoors, minimizing transplant shock.

Toilet paper roll seed starters are especially popular among urban gardeners or those with limited outdoor space, as they provide a simple way to start a garden from seeds.

Despite its many benefits, it’s important to note that this method isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution and isn’t suitable for all types of seeds, which we will explore further in this blog post.

What Seeds Should Not Be Planted In Toilet Paper Rolls
What Seeds Should Not Be Planted In Toilet Paper Rolls

Importance of Understanding the Proper Seed Types to Use in this Method

For several reasons, understanding the proper seed types to use in toilet paper roll planting is crucial.

Firstly, the seed size and the root system’s eventual size matter. Toilet paper rolls are relatively small, limiting the growing space for roots. This means that plants with large seeds or those that develop extensive root systems might become root-bound, stunting their growth and causing stress to the plant.

Secondly, some plants need to handle the transplanting process better, even when the entire biodegradable pot is planted. These plants prefer to be sown directly in their permanent location, so they aren’t the best candidates for this method.

Lastly, seeds that require special conditions for germination may not be suited to toilet paper roll planting. For instance, some seeds might need specific soil pH levels, light conditions, or brutal temperatures to manage in small containers.

By understanding which seeds are appropriate for this method, gardeners can better utilize toilet paper roll planting to its full potential, fostering healthier plants and, ultimately, a more successful garden.

Understanding Toilet Paper Roll Planting

Toilet paper roll planting is a creative and environmentally friendly method of starting seedlings indoors. This method involves using empty toilet paper rolls as biodegradable pots for seeds. These seed starters can then be directly transplanted into the garden, minimizing transplant shock as the roots aren’t disturbed.

Here’s how it generally works:

  • The empty toilet paper rolls are cut in half and arranged in a tray.
  • The halves are filled with potting soil or a seed-starting mix.
  • Seeds are then sown in the soil, following each seed type’s recommended depth and spacing.
  • The tray is watered and kept warm until the seeds germinate.
  • Once the seedlings are hardy enough and the outdoor conditions are right, they can be transplanted directly into the garden or larger pots, with the toilet paper roll disintegrating naturally over time.

While this method has many advantages, such as being cost-effective and reducing waste, it also has some limitations. For one, the size of a toilet paper roll is relatively tiny, restricting the root growth of certain plants.

Furthermore, not all seed types are suitable for this method due to various growth factors, which we’ll delve into in the following sections. Understanding these limitations helps to use this method effectively and successfully.

Advantages of Toilet Paper Roll Planting

Toilet paper roll planting offers several advantages that make it an appealing choice for gardeners:

Eco-Friendly: By reusing toilet paper rolls that would otherwise be discarded, you’re taking a small but significant step towards reducing waste and promoting sustainability. Plus, the rolls biodegrade naturally over time once planted, leaving no trace in the soil.

Cost-Effective: Since toilet paper rolls are a common household waste item, utilizing them for planting seeds eliminates the need to buy commercial seed starter pots, helping you save money.

Easy Transplanting: Since the whole roll can be planted directly into the ground or a larger pot, it minimizes root disturbance and transplant shock—a common issue that can stunt or even kill a plant’s growth. The roots can continue to grow freely through the decomposing roll.

Ideal for Certain Plants: Toilet paper roll planting is excellent for certain seed types that can thrive in these conditions, especially those that benefit from an early indoor start and don’t mind transplanted, such as tomatoes, lettuce, or peas.

Compact: Toilet paper roll seed starters are small and lightweight, allowing you to start many seedlings in a limited space.

Educational: For families with children, this method provides a fun and educational DIY gardening project, promoting learning about growth cycles, recycling, and nature.

Even though the advantages are persuasive, it’s essential to remember that not all seeds are appropriate for toilet paper roll planting because of the plant’s size and growth needs. To achieve success with this approach, selecting the right seeds is critical.

Limitations of Toilet Paper Roll Planting

While toilet paper roll planting presents numerous benefits, it has its limitations. Understanding these can help you decide if it’s the proper seed-starting method for you and, if so, which seeds to choose.

Limited Space: Toilet paper rolls offer restricted space for root growth. This can be problematic for plants with larger seeds or those that grow extensive root systems, as they may become root-bound and stunted.

Decomposition: While it’s beneficial that toilet paper rolls decompose naturally if your seedlings aren’t ready for transplanting when the roll starts to decompose, it can lead to difficulties. It might become flimsy and fall apart, or mold could develop.

Water Management: Toilet paper rolls can dry out quickly, requiring diligent watering. On the flip side, they can also retain too much moisture and lead to waterlogged conditions, potentially causing root rot.

Transplant Shock: Although the method helps minimize transplant shock, certain plants don’t handle the transplanting process well and prefer to be sown directly into their permanent growing location.

Unsuitable for Certain Seeds: Some seeds have specific germination requirements in light, temperature, and soil conditions that are difficult to meet with toilet paper roll planting.

Awareness of these limitations can guide your decisions on what seeds to plant in toilet paper rolls and how best to care for them to ensure healthy growth.

Description of Various Seed Types

Seeds come in all shapes, sizes, and types, each with unique germination and growth requirements. Here’s a broad categorization of seeds based on their characteristics:

  1. Large Seeds: Examples include beans, corn, pumpkin, and squash. These seeds are sizeable and require substantial soil to cover them. They also tend to sprout larger seedlings, needing more room for their roots to grow.
  2. Medium Seeds: These include seeds like peas, cucumbers, and sunflowers. While smaller than the category above, they still require sufficient space for their roots to develop.
  3. Small Seeds: Examples include lettuce, radishes, and carrots. These tiny seeds require a thin layer of soil to cover them. They also usually produce smaller seedlings initially.
  4. Deep-Rooting Seeds: This includes carrots, parsnips, and daikon growing long taproot. These seeds need a deep container for unhindered root growth.
  5. Surface-Sowing Seeds: Some seeds require light to germinate and should be sown on the soil surface or covered with a very light layer. Many herb and flower seeds fall into this category.
  6. Special-Sowing Condition Seeds: Some seeds need specific conditions to germinate. For example, strawberries need a period of cold stratification, and certain herbs need alternating temperatures or particular light conditions.

Each seed type has different requirements in terms of space, depth, light, and temperature, so it’s crucial to know what seeds you’re working with before you sow them, especially when considering using a method like a toilet paper roll planting.

Specific Planting Requirements of Different Seeds

Different seeds have varying requirements for successful germination and growth. Here’s a general outline of some specific planting requirements for different types of seeds:

Large Seeds: Beans, corn, pumpkin, and squash typically need to be planted more profoundly into the soil – usually around 1-2 inches deep. They also need more space for their root system to grow, requiring a larger pot or direct sowing into the garden.

Medium Seeds: Seeds like peas, cucumbers, and sunflowers must be planted about 1 inch deep. They also require a fair amount of space to grow their root systems, so consider a medium-sized pot or direct sowing.

Small Seeds: These include lettuce, radishes, and carrots. Such seeds should be planted closer to the soil surface, about 1/4-1/2 inch deep. These seeds are often sown densely and thinned out as they grow.

Deep-Rooting Seeds: Plants like carrots, parsnips, and daikon need a lot of vertical space for their roots, so they should be planted in deep containers or directly in a garden bed. The soil should be loose and rock-free to allow the roots to grow long and straight.

Surface-Sowing Seeds: Some seeds need light to germinate and should be sown directly on the soil surface or covered with a very light dusting of soil. Many herb and flower seeds fall into this category.

Special-Sowing Condition Seeds: Certain seeds need specific conditions to germinate. For instance, strawberries need a period of cold stratification, where the seeds are exposed to cold and moist conditions for a certain period. Some herbs need alternating temperatures or specific light conditions to germinate.

These are general guidelines, and individual plant species may have specific requirements. Always check the seed packet or consult a gardening expert for the best results.

The Importance of Root Space for Different Plant Types

Root space is crucial for plant growth and health for several reasons. Understanding its significance can help ensure the success of your gardening efforts.

Nutrient Uptake: Roots absorb water and nutrients from the soil. The more room roots have to grow and spread, the more nutrients they can absorb, promoting healthier and more robust plant growth.

Stability: A well-established root system provides stability, helping the plant to stand upright and resist wind and rain.

Water Management: A larger root system can access a greater volume of soil, increasing the plant’s capacity to take up and store water and making it more resilient during periods of drought.

Growth Impact: The size and health of a plant’s root system directly impact its top growth. If the roots are cramped or root-bound, they can stunt the plant’s growth, limit fruit production, and even cause it to wilt or die.

Different plant types have varying root space requirements based on size, growth habits, and specific needs. Large plants, deep-rooted plants, or those that naturally spread their roots widely will need more root space compared to smaller or shallow-rooted plants.

Understanding this aspect is vital in the context of toilet paper roll planting. The limited space may only suit some seeds, potentially leading to unsuccessful growth or unhealthy plants.

Seeds That Are Not Suitable for Toilet Paper Roll Planting

Given the limitations of toilet paper roll planting, several types of seeds may not be ideally suited for this method:

Large Seeds: Large seeds like beans, squash, corn, and pumpkin can quickly outgrow the small confines of a toilet paper roll, leading to stunted growth or overly crowded conditions.

Deep-Rooting Plants: Some plants, like carrots, parsnips, and beets, grow a deep primary root or “taproot.” The limited depth of toilet paper rolls doesn’t give these plants the necessary space to grow correctly.

Seeds with Special Sowing Conditions: Certain sources have unique germination requirements that can be challenging to meet with toilet paper roll planting.

For example, strawberries need a cold stratification period before germinating, and some herbs require specific light conditions or alternating temperatures.

Plants Sensitive to Transplanting: Certain plants, like dill, cilantro, or peas, don’t tolerate being transplanted well. These plants prefer to be directly sown in their final growing location and may suffer from transplant shock if started in a toilet paper roll.

Plants that Need Lots of Water: Toilet paper rolls can dry out quickly, and seeds that need consistently moist soil might need to do better. Conversely, if you overwater, the rolls can retain too much moisture and cause root rot.

Best Practices for Toilet Paper Roll Planting

Toilet paper roll planting can be a great way to start your seeds if you know its limitations and follow best practices. Here are some tips to help ensure success:

Choose the Right Seeds: As discussed, not all seeds are suitable for this method. Choose seeds of plants that don’t mind being transplanted, have smaller seeds, and don’t require a large root space.

Prepare Your Rolls Correctly: Cut your toilet paper rolls in half to create a suitable depth for most seed types. Ensure the rolls are stable in your seed tray so they won’t tip over as the plants grow.

Use Quality Soil: Use a good quality, well-draining seed starting mix. This type of soil is typically lighter and fluffier than regular potting soil, allowing for better root growth and preventing waterlogging.

Moisture Management: Keep the soil moist but not soggy. Too much water can cause toilet paper rolls to decompose prematurely or encourage mold growth. Too little water can cause the soil to dry out quickly, which could harm your seedlings.

Hardening Off: Before transplanting, harden off your seedlings by gradually introducing them to outdoor conditions. This helps to prepare them for the change in environment and reduces the risk of transplant shock.

Transplant at the Right Time: Transplant your seedlings before the rolls decompose significantly while the plant is still small enough to handle the transition. The right timing will vary depending on the plant type and growth rate.

Care After Transplanting: Once transplanted, provide appropriate care based on each plant’s requirements for sunlight, watering, and feeding.

Alternatives to Toilet Paper Roll Planting for Unsuitable Seeds

There are many other methods to consider for seeds that aren’t suitable for toilet paper roll planting. Let’s look at a few alternatives:

Commercial Seed Trays: These trays are designed specifically for starting seeds and come in various sizes. They typically have a flat tray for holding water, a tray with individual cells for each plant, and a clear dome to create a mini greenhouse environment.

Peat or Coir Pots: These pots are made from peat moss or coconut fiber and, like toilet paper rolls, can be planted directly into the ground. They come in larger sizes, accommodating bigger seeds or plants that need more root space.

Biodegradable Pots: Other types of biodegradable pots are available on the market, such as ones made from cow manure or recycled paper. They can also be planted directly in the ground, offering more space than toilet paper rolls.

Direct Sowing: Direct sowing into the garden or a larger pot can be the best option for plants that don’t like to be transplanted, such as root vegetables or sensitive herbs.

DIY Pots: You can make your seed starting pots from various materials. For example, you can create newspaper pots using a simple folding technique. These newspaper pots are larger than toilet paper rolls and are biodegradable.

Repurposed Containers: You can also repurpose various containers as seed starters. Yogurt cups, egg cartons, or even cut-off milk jugs can be effective and virtually free seed starting pots.

Final Thoughts

Toilet paper roll planting is a sustainable, cost-effective method that’s perfect for many types of seeds. However, understanding the limitations of this method is crucial.

Not all seeds are well-suited to this approach. Larger seeds, deep-rooting plants, seeds with special sowing conditions, plants sensitive to transplanting, and plants that require a lot of water may not thrive in toilet paper rolls.

To ensure your gardening success, it’s essential to understand the specific needs of the seeds you’re working with. Choose methods best suited to those needs: toilet paper rolls, commercial seed trays, DIY pots, or direct sowing.

By investing time in understanding your seeds’ unique characteristics and requirements, you’ll be well-prepared to nurture them from sowing to harvest, regardless of the method you choose.

FAQs on What Seeds Should Not Be Planted In Toilet Paper Rolls

Q: Can you plant seeds in toilet paper rolls?

A: Yes, you can plant seeds in toilet paper rolls. It’s a popular method for starting seeds as it’s cost-effective and environmentally friendly.

It’s worth noting that this method may not be suitable for all types of seeds, as their size and unique germination requirements can affect their success.

Q: Are toilet paper rolls safe for gardening?

A: Yes, toilet paper rolls are safe for gardening. They are made from paper, which is biodegradable and will decompose in the soil over time.

However, be sure to use toilet paper rolls with no inks or dyes if you are concerned about potential contaminants.

Q: How do you plant seeds with empty toilet paper rolls?

A: To plant seeds with empty toilet paper rolls, cut the rolls in half and then place them in a tray that can hold water. Fill each roll with good quality, well-draining seed-starting mix, then plant your seeds according to the depth recommended for that particular species.

Keep the soil consistently moist but not waterlogged, and provide the necessary light and temperature conditions for the seeds you are sowing.

Q: Do all seeds germinate in paper towel?

A: No, not all seeds will germinate in a paper towel. While many seeds can be started this way, others may require specific soil conditions or light exposure to grow.

Additionally, seeds of plants that are sensitive to transplanting may not do well with the paper towel method as it requires you to move the germinated seed into soil.

Q: Does toilet paper decompose in soil?

A: Yes, toilet paper decomposes in soil. It’s made from paper, a natural material that will break down over time when exposed to the elements and microorganisms in the soil.

This makes toilet paper rolls an environmentally-friendly choice for seed-starting containers. However, if they’re kept too wet, they can decompose before the seedlings can be transplanted.

You may also like...